Independent Inquiry Into Child Sexual Abuse (From The August 2020 Newsletter)
The IICSA says the Truth Project has now heard from more than 5,000 victims and survivors of child sexual abuse. Of these, 4,269 personal accounts have been analysed for research purposes.
All have made an important contribution to the Inquiry’s work to better protect children in future.
Launched in 2015, the Truth Project provides a safe and supportive way for survivors to share their accounts and put forward suggestions for change.
It is drawing to a close next year so that all of the experiences shared can be used to inform the findings in the Inquiry’s final report, due to be published in 2022.
The IICSA has found that more than one in 10 victims and survivors who have come forward to the Truth Project are speaking out about their experience for the first time.
Survivors spoke of abuse taking place across a range of institutions such as schools, religious settings and residential care, as well as sports and the armed forces. They also talked about experiencing abuse in their family setting and of being failed by someone in authority. Whilst nearly half reported living with an illness or condition that affects their everyday lives, almost all of those who shared their accounts described some form of impact after experiencing abuse in childhood, with 87 percent describing an effect on their mental health.
In addition to the sexual abuse, more than half of survivors described experiencing other forms of abuse during childhood, such as physical, psychological and emotional. The majority said they had not told anyone about the child sexual abuse at the time it was happening.
Today, the Inquiry is also publishing a further 80 Experiences Shared with the Truth Project.
These accounts show that even when victims tried to report abuse, they were threatened, ignored or told to stay silent.
Analetta said the abuser used threats to control her, threatening to hurt her family if she didn’t do what he demanded. He also told her that everyone would think she was ‘dirty’ if they found out about it.
Through their accounts, survivors also describe changes they hope to see in future, such as further education, improved societal understanding and greater awareness of the impact of child sexual abuse. Many said that by sharing their account, they hoped to help others who had been through a similar experience.
Maksud was sexually abused by a religious leader. He says that speaking out about this might help to address the stigma and shame that too often silences victims of abuse in his community.
The Truth Project gives survivors the opportunity to share as much or as little as they want about their experiences without question, challenge or judgement. It’s drawing to a close next year so that all of the experiences shared can be used to inform the Inquiry’s Final Report and recommendations, due for publication in 2022, so children are better protected in the future. Survivors who would like to share their experience with the Truth Project can do so in writing, over the telephone or by video call. More information about how to share can be found on the Truth Project website.
1b . The Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA) has published new research exploring the challenges faced by victims and survivors in accessing statutory, private and voluntary sector support services.
Commissioned by the Inquiry and carried out by independent research consultants Broome|Gekoski in conjunction with the University of Hertfordshire, the report analyses the support service experiences of over 180 victims and survivors. It considers a number of key areas including survivors’ awareness of the services available to them, barriers to access and reasons for not doing so, as well as the effectiveness of services in meeting the needs of survivors.
The report finds that nearly three quarters of survivors reported not having accessed any support services, with just over a quarter having received some form of support, advice or treatment due to their experience of child sexual abuse.
It shows that the vast majority of survivors (84 percent) faced at least one barrier to access, with survivors citing personal, financial and community challenges which had stopped, delayed or discouraged them from accessing support. Whilst some participants felt unable to access support due to not feeling brave enough or that they were to blame or because of fears that they wouldn’t be believed, others said they simply didn’t know where to turn.
The report shines a light on the role of support services in the healing and recovery process, with survivors who sought to access support stressing the importance of being listened to, understood, believed, and not judged, by caring and empathetic professionals.
Whilst many participants noted that services are better now than they were in the past, almost half felt that they currently had unmet needs linked to their experience of child sexual abuse, putting forward their own suggestions on how support services could be improved. This included better training for professionals, less reliance on medication, gender specific support and help being made available as soon as it’s needed.
1c . Following the initial two week public hearing in May earlier this year, The Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA) will continue to examine child protection policies and safeguarding cultures in religious organisations in England and Wales.
These include Jehovah’s Witnesses, Baptists, Methodists, Islam, Judaism, Sikhism, Hinduism, Buddhism and non-conformist Christian denominations.
Evidence will be heard from a wide range of witnesses, including victims and survivors, religious organisations, charities, local authorities, central government and third sector bodies who provide training and support in the field.
This investigation will focus on the measures religious organisations employ to keep children safe from sexual abuse and to properly handle safeguarding concerns.
Witnesses will continue to be supported by the Inquiry’s Support and Safeguarding team, through phone and video calls.
This is what some Truth Project participants have said about the experience:
“It is such a relief to go to sleep at night knowing that someone, somewhere is doing something to try to ensure a safer future for vulnerable children. It wasn't easy sharing my story but the kind, empathic staff at the IICSA supported me through it. I was listened to, believed and understood. I was given a voice and that is so very valuable. For the first time I feel truly hopeful that things might change for the better and maybe suffering will stop.”
“After suffering violent physical and sexual abuse at the age of 10, I took the opportunity to explain what had happened. I was welcomed with kindness and consideration and was able to relate what happened. I just wanted to be able to put on record the pain, humiliation and degradation that I suffered at the hands of a man who was supposed to educate and inform. I am extremely grateful that I was able to do this. A heartfelt thankyou to all those involved in the Inquiry.”
Seven Case Reviews Added
3. Seven case reviews have been added to the collection this month featuring a number of issues including autism, child sexual abuse, children with disabilities and suicide. They are:
a.Published by Coventry Safeguarding Children Board is serious sexual abuse of eight children, several of whom have disabilities including one child with serious physical and learning difficulties, by members of Family S. Review covers abuse during the period August 2010 - May 2016. Criminal proceedings resulted in several adults receiving custodial sentences from four years to life imprisonment. The children had all come to the attention of statutory services over a number of years due to neglect by their carers. Evidence of indirect or incomplete disclosures, both verbal and non-verbal. A police investigation into disclosure of sexual abuse made to a foster carer in 2015 was closed within a matter of weeks with no further action. A second police investigation, triggered by information emerging out of Family Court procedures, uncovered repeated abuse of a number of children by members of Family S, a family where sexual abuse of children had become normalised over at least three generations. All of the children are white British. Issues identified include: the need to hear the voice of the child, and not the louder voice of adults; need to develop knowledge of sexual abuse in relation to disabled children and ways to provide opportunities for non-verbal children to communicate; and the impact of gender on the on the response of services. The review followed a systems-based methodology. Recommendations to the Safeguarding Board include: develop skills and knowledge in communicating with children who disclose sexual abuse; embed understanding of grooming and sexual offending in practice; and ensure a clear pathway is in place for identifying and working with complex intra familial sexual abuse.
b. Published by Hertfordshire Safeguarding Children Partnership about the death of a 16-year-old boy by suicide. Case review covers the period from January 2012 to December 2017. There were no services involved with Child K at the time of his death apart from school. An initial child protection conference was triggered due to Child K's plans to run away to his family's country of origin and his threats to teachers and other pupils. School made a referral to the Channel Panel and he was made the subject of a child protection plan. After this, his engagement with professionals declined. Concerns about the effects of domestic abuse in the household. Father was controlling and there were sporadic acts of violence. Child K was diagnosed with an autistic spectrum disorder. Shortly before his death, Child K made a report to the police which suggested his actions may result in risk to himself. Ethnicity/nationality not stated. Findings include: Child K was seen differently by different people; Child K's needs in relation to his autism rarely featured in multi-agency meetings; and Child K felt that the involvement of professionals in his family's life was a significant disruption. Recommendations include: consider a trauma-informed relational approach; consider whether practice and service provision is sensitive to the cultural, historic and gender context of families, including those outside of the main Black and Minority Ethnic groups; and review cases of domestic abuse before closure to confirm that couples and children have been signposted to counselling or meditation services.
c. Published by Kent Safeguarding Children Board about the death of a 16-year-old girl in 2017 by suicide. Carys and her sister lived with their mother and stepfather and his two children. Carys experienced anxiety and was in receipt of mental health services. Early in 2017 Carys and her sister disclosed to their mother that their stepfather had been sexually abusing them; he was arrested and has subsequently been convicted for the offences. Following the disclosure and investigation, but before the criminal trial, Carys took her own life. Ethnicity or nationality not stated. Learning focuses on issues around: initial responses to disclosures of child sexual abuse; use of child sexual abuse pathways and associated support; responses to the mental health needs of Carys; education settings being identified as key safeguarding partners; sharing of adult safeguarding information and concerns; accurate record-keeping by professionals; follow-up for children not brought to health appointments. Recommendations to the Safeguarding Children Board include: to require an audit of strategy meetings to ensure participation from partners is sufficiently inclusive, follow up is occurring as necessary and effective information gathering and sharing is taking place; ensure rigorous promotion of the role of the Sexual Assault Referral Centre to ensure victims of sexual abuse, including nonrecent abuse, are being offered holistic support; explore ways to widely promote existing pathways and opportunities to respond to mental health issues in children and young people, including the policy to manage self-harming and suicidal behaviour; request assurance from health partners that missed health appointments for children are subject to robust and consistent follow up.
d. Published by Luton Safeguarding Board is about the neglect and sexual abuse of secondary-school-age child. Legal proceedings took several years, and Child G is now an adult. Child G's school made referral to social work team about Child G's angry behaviours, self-harming and allegations about abuse at home. Strategy meeting and interview with Child G by a police officer and a social worker; core assessment and medical assessment were not carried out. An Interim Care Order made and Child G was placed with a foster carer. Ethnicity or nationality not stated. Learning includes: missed opportunities for a holistic and multi-agency assessment and response to Child G's emotional needs; no evidence of chronologies being maintained or information being collated to enable a wider understanding of Child G's history; there was a need for better management and supervision; ensure appropriate use of specialists to provide advice on how to engage with the child/adult if they have learning needs; practitioners need to be curious about the causal nature of behaviour and seek to explore alternative reasons. Recommendations to the Safeguarding Children Board include: ensure that agencies have in place and follow effective safeguarding supervision and management oversight procedures, and remind agencies of the importance of appropriate challenge and escalation; establish clear self-harm procedures and pathways; ensure that effective support is provided to disabled children and their families to enable them to communicate and effectively participate in plans; ensure compliance with the procedures for child protection medicals and the inclusion of consultant paediatricians in strategy discussions or meetings.
e. Published by Cardiff and Vale of Glamorgan Regional Safeguarding Children Board is about life-threatening injuries to a 3-year-old child in March 2016. The child was found lifeless by an older sibling, hanging from a soft toy trapped on the top rail of a bunk bed. Ambulance services were called three times before enough information enabled paramedics to attend and take the child to hospital, where they recovered. Concerns recorded by Police related to home environment, particularly lack of food and toiletries, and poor cleanliness. History of substance abuse, child supervision concerns, and domestic abuse in the family home. Children were subject to child protection plans for emotional abuse and neglect. Reports to Police from neighbours and Mother relating to anti-social behaviour and domestic incidents prior to the incident. Learning includes: children's behaviour can be a means of communication and lively and unpredictable conduct could be indicative of exposure to domestic violence; clearer case management with specific advice regarding interventions may have prevented more incidents occurring and triggered further child protection enquiries; provide training for frontline staff in relation to recognising and implementing strategies for disguised compliance at an early stage. Ethnicity and nationality not stated. Recommendations include: consider alternative approaches to capturing the child's voice forms part of any 'direct work with children' training and part of the mentoring process for social workers in their first year of practice; consider if letters or other more suitable forms of communication depending on their particular needs, advising families of the decision to conduct a Child Practice Review are delivered by the most appropriate person.
f. Published by London Borough of Wandsworth Safeguarding Children Board is about non-accidental injuries to a 4-month old girl in 2015. Child AA (Baby Eliza) was taken to hospital by ambulance where examination revealed unexplained cerebral bleeding thought to have occurred more than once. Mother was a single parent; had been in care when she was 15. Maternal history of: mental health problems; drug abuse; domestic abuse; reluctance to engage with services; sexual abuse and exploitation; multiple pregnancies. Wider family known to multiple agencies. A previous child had been removed because of parental neglect. Pre-and post-birth assessments had not raised serious concerns; plan to support Child AA as a child in need. Child AA is Black British. Learning includes: need for thorough assessment of mother's and wider family history, including trauma when assessing parenting capacity rather than depending only upon presentation and observations; need to avoid misplaced sympathy; need to consider correlation between animal cruelty and child abuse; importance of following best practice and compliance with established procedures; need for professional curiosity and mutual challenge; need for full, precise and accurate information recording and sharing; persistence in encouraging GP involvement; professional enquiry about men (resident or not) whose relationship and conduct had an impact on the case; need for an effective system for identifying safeguarding supervision cases. Makes specific recommendations to all agencies involved including changes in policy and procedures as well as steps to ensure sharing, accurate, up-to-date information. Recommendations to the Safeguarding Board include: use the case for multi-agency training; urge NHS England to ensure clinics inform GPs of terminations.
g. Published by Sandwell Safeguarding Children Board about the death of an 8-week-old baby in 2017. KS was placed in bed next to Mother where they both fell asleep. Mother's partner awoke to find KS still in bed lying on their back and not breathing. Ambulance services were called and attempts to resuscitate KS were made, but KS was declared deceased at hospital. Parents were arrested and a police investigation was conducted and concluded with no further action. Mother had seven children including KS and twin, with some the subject of child protection plans, care proceedings and child in need plans. History of domestic abuse between Mother and children's fathers. Mother had failed to attend and bring KS to many health appointments and had a history of substance misuse. Methodology based on the 'Welsh Model'. Key findings include: KS died from an unascertained cause and there was no known action that professionals in Sandwell could have taken to prevent this death; if agencies had better shared information and complied with both national and local procedures, the level of support to Mother and her family could have been more effective but would not have affected the final tragic outcome for KS. Ethnicity or nationality not stated. Recommendations include: undertake a review of safeguarding training to ensure that pre-birth procedures are understood and implemented appropriately; seek assurance that health professionals engaged in antenatal and post-natal work are trained in the appropriate use and application of escalation procedures, issues of disguised compliance and over optimistic assessments.
SAFE is a not-for-profit Community Interest Company focused exclusively on safeguarding. Every penny profit we make is ploughed back into the charitable and community sector so voluntary organisations and charities can benefit from SAFE’s expert services for subsidised prices. We provide a one-stop solution for everything from DBS checks, policy creation and guidance, safeguarding management briefings and incident support, to training (both face to face and online). We have already trained thousands of staff and volunteers, providing thousands of hours of CPD (Continuing Professional Development). All SAFE courses meet the training requirements of the latest legislation, government guidance, local Adult and Child Safeguarding Boards (Adult Protection Committees and Local Area Child Protection Committees in Scotland), CQC and Ofsted.
© SAFE CIC 2020